Split/Shared Visit Billing in Medicare: Who Bills, Decided by the Substantive Portion

Direct answer: A split/shared visit is an evaluation and management service performed in part by a physician and in part by a nonphysician practitioner, such as a nurse practitioner or physician assistant, from the same group practice, for the same patient on the same calendar day, in a facility setting. One visit is billed, not two, and the practitioner who performs the substantive portion of the visit bills it under their own National Provider Identifier. Under the rule CMS finalised for 2024, the substantive portion means more than half of the total time spent on the visit, or a substantive part of the medical decision making. Modifier FS goes on the claim to identify the service as a split/shared visit. When the physician bills, Medicare pays 100 percent of the physician fee schedule; when the nonphysician practitioner bills, Medicare pays 85 percent of the fee schedule.
What a Split/Shared Visit Is
A split/shared visit is a medically necessary evaluation and management service that two practitioners share. The physician and the nonphysician practitioner each personally perform part of the same visit, on the same calendar day, for the same patient, in a facility setting. Both practitioners must be in the same group practice, under the same tax identification number, and both must be enrolled in Medicare with evaluation and management services in their scope of practice. The service is reported once, under the National Provider Identifier of the practitioner who performed the substantive portion. It is not two visits, and it is not a visit billed once by each practitioner. If only one practitioner performed the visit, it is not a split/shared visit at all, and it bills under that practitioner alone.
The Substantive Portion Test: Time or Medical Decision Making
The substantive portion decides who bills, and the 2024 rule gives two ways to meet it. The first way is time: the billing practitioner personally spent more than half of the total time both practitioners spent on the visit. Total time means the combined time of both practitioners, and time the two spend together with the patient counts once, not twice. The second way is medical decision making: the billing practitioner made or approved the medical decision making for the visit. Medical decision making is measured through the number and complexity of the problems addressed, the amount and complexity of the data reviewed and analysed, and the risk of complications or of morbidity or mortality from the management plan. Either pathway is enough. History taking and physical examination no longer count toward the substantive portion, because CMS no longer allows history or examination as the justification for split/shared billing. If the visit level is selected by time, the substantive portion test must also be time; the two choices must match.
The Time-Only Transition: What to Know
The timing of this rule has caused confusion, so it is worth stating plainly. CMS originally planned to move to a time-only test for the substantive portion, and delayed that move more than once. Some guides date the planned change to 2025, while another current guide states that neither CMS nor the CPT guidelines changed this policy in 2025, 2026, or 2027. What is settled is the rule in effect now: the 2024 dual-pathway test, more than half of the total time or a substantive part of the medical decision making. Bill under that rule, and check the current CMS Physician Fee Schedule rule each year before assuming the test has changed.
Facility Only: Where Split/Shared Billing Applies, and Where It Does Not
Split/shared billing applies only in facility settings. That means inpatient hospital, outpatient hospital, observation, emergency department, and skilled nursing facility settings. It never applies in the office, place of service 11. In the office, the incident-to rules apply instead, and a shared office visit bills under incident-to, not as a split/shared visit. Getting the setting wrong is one of the most common split/shared errors: a visit shared in the office cannot be turned into a split/shared claim by adding modifier FS, because the facility rule is a condition of the billing method itself, not a documentation choice. Commercial payers do not all follow the Medicare rule, so check each payer policy before submitting a split/shared claim to a non-Medicare payer.
Modifier FS: Required on Every Split/Shared Claim
Modifier FS, for split or shared evaluation and management service, must be appended to the evaluation and management code on every split/shared claim, whichever practitioner bills the visit. It is required when the physician bills and when the nonphysician practitioner bills, so do not leave it off a claim billed under the nonphysician practitioner National Provider Identifier. Modifier FS does not reduce payment. It is an informational modifier that identifies the claim as a split/shared visit for audit and tracking, and CMS monitors split/shared billing through it. Omitting modifier FS risks denial or an audit flag, because the claim then looks like an ordinary visit billed by one practitioner.
Who Gets Paid What: 100 Percent or 85 Percent
The payment difference is the reason the substantive portion matters. When the physician performs the substantive portion and bills under the physician National Provider Identifier, Medicare pays 100 percent of the physician fee schedule for the service. When the nonphysician practitioner performs the substantive portion and bills under their own National Provider Identifier, Medicare pays 85 percent of the fee schedule. The modifier does not change the rate; the billing practitioner does. That is why the substantive portion must be decided from the record, not from who happened to enter the charge. Billing under the physician when the nonphysician practitioner performed the substantive portion overstates the payment, and billing under the nonphysician practitioner when the physician performed the substantive portion understates it.
Critical Care Uses Time Only
Critical care is the exception to the dual pathway. Critical care code selection does not use medical decision making, so the substantive portion for a critical care service must be based on time. The practitioner who personally furnishes more than half of the total critical care time bills the critical care code, with modifier FS. Do not use a medical decision making argument to support a split/shared critical care claim, because there is no medical decision making basis to argue from.
Documentation: What the Record Must Show
The record must identify both practitioners who performed the visit, and it must show what each one did. The billing practitioner, the one who performed the substantive portion, must sign and date the medical record. When medical decision making is the basis for the substantive portion, the record must document that decision making, because CMS expects whoever performs the medical decision making and bills the visit to have documented it in the medical record. When time is the basis, each practitioner documents their own time, so the total and the majority can be worked out from the record. A note that names only one practitioner, or a note signed by someone who did not perform the substantive portion, does not support a split/shared claim. Build the template so both practitioners record their own contribution, their own time, and, where relevant, their part in the medical decision making, before the charge is entered.
Worked Example, an Illustrative Time and MDM Comparison
Every figure in this example is illustrative. A physician and a nurse practitioner from the same group see the same patient in the hospital on the same day. The nurse practitioner spends 20 minutes on the visit and the physician spends 25 minutes, so the total time is 45 minutes. More than half of 45 minutes is anything over 22 minutes and 30 seconds, so the physician, at 25 minutes, performed the substantive portion by time. The visit bills once under the physician National Provider Identifier, with modifier FS, at 100 percent of the fee schedule. Now change only the times: the nurse practitioner spends 30 minutes and the physician spends 15 minutes, so the total time is still 45 minutes, but the nurse practitioner performed the substantive portion by time. The visit bills once under the nurse practitioner National Provider Identifier, with modifier FS, at 85 percent of the fee schedule. Now keep the second set of times but change the decision making: the nurse practitioner spends 30 minutes, the physician spends 15 minutes, and the physician makes the medical decision making for the visit and documents it. The physician performed the substantive portion by medical decision making, even though the nurse practitioner spent more time, so the visit bills once under the physician National Provider Identifier, with modifier FS, at 100 percent of the fee schedule. That is the dual pathway in action: time and medical decision making are two separate routes to the same answer, and the record must show which route was used.
| Scenario, all figures illustrative | Total time | Who performed the substantive portion | Who bills, with modifier FS | Medicare payment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Physician 25 minutes, nurse practitioner 20 minutes | 45 minutes | Physician, by time, more than half | Physician NPI | 100 percent of the fee schedule |
| Nurse practitioner 30 minutes, physician 15 minutes | 45 minutes | Nurse practitioner, by time, more than half | Nurse practitioner NPI | 85 percent of the fee schedule |
| Nurse practitioner 30 minutes, physician 15 minutes, physician made the medical decision making | 45 minutes | Physician, by medical decision making | Physician NPI | 100 percent of the fee schedule |
| Physician and nurse practitioner share a critical care service, physician 40 minutes, nurse practitioner 20 minutes | 60 minutes of critical care time | Physician, by time only, more than half | Physician NPI | 100 percent of the fee schedule |
Common Mistakes That Produce a Denial or an Audit Flag
The most common mistake is billing a split/shared visit in the office, place of service 11, where incident-to rules apply instead. The second is leaving modifier FS off the claim, including on claims billed under the nonphysician practitioner. The third is deciding the billing practitioner from history or examination, which no longer counts toward the substantive portion. The fourth is billing under the physician by default, even when the nonphysician practitioner performed the substantive portion, which overstates the payment. The fifth is a record that names only one practitioner, or is signed by someone who did not perform the substantive portion. The sixth is using medical decision making to support a split/shared critical care claim, where only time counts. The seventh is applying the Medicare rule to a commercial payer without checking that payer policy first.
Checklist
- Confirm the visit is an evaluation and management service in a facility setting, inpatient hospital, outpatient hospital, observation, emergency department, or skilled nursing facility, and not in the office.
- Confirm both practitioners are in the same group practice, enrolled in Medicare, and saw the patient on the same calendar day.
- Work out the substantive portion from the record: more than half of the total time, or the practitioner who made or approved the medical decision making.
- For critical care, use time only.
- Confirm the record identifies both practitioners and what each one did, and that the billing practitioner signed and dated it.
- Confirm the medical decision making is documented in the record when it is the basis for the substantive portion.
- Bill the visit once, under the National Provider Identifier of the practitioner who performed the substantive portion.
- Append modifier FS to the evaluation and management code on the claim, whichever practitioner bills.
- Check the payer policy before submitting a split/shared claim to a commercial payer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a split/shared visit in Medicare billing?
An evaluation and management service in a facility setting performed in part by a physician and in part by a nonphysician practitioner from the same group, for the same patient on the same calendar day, billed once under the practitioner who performed the substantive portion.
What is the substantive portion of a split/shared visit?
Under the 2024 rule, more than half of the total time spent on the visit, or a substantive part of the medical decision making, meaning the practitioner who made or approved the medical decision making.
Does history or examination count toward the substantive portion?
No. CMS no longer allows history or examination as the justification for split/shared billing.
Can a split/shared visit be billed in the office?
No. Split/shared billing applies only in facility settings. In the office, place of service 11, the incident-to rules apply instead.
Is modifier FS required on split/shared claims?
Yes. Modifier FS must be appended to the evaluation and management code on every split/shared claim, whether the physician or the nonphysician practitioner bills.
Does modifier FS reduce payment?
No. It is an informational modifier, and the payment rate depends on which practitioner bills.
How much does Medicare pay for a split/shared visit?
When the physician bills, 100 percent of the physician fee schedule; when the nonphysician practitioner bills, 85 percent of the fee schedule.
How is the substantive portion decided for critical care?
By time only, because critical care code selection does not use medical decision making. The practitioner who furnishes more than half of the total critical care time bills the service.
Who must sign the record for a split/shared visit?
The billing practitioner, the one who performed the substantive portion, must sign and date the medical record, and the record must identify both practitioners.
Has the substantive portion rule changed to time only?
CMS planned a move to time-only and delayed it more than once, and sources differ on the later dates. The rule in effect now is the 2024 dual-pathway test, time or medical decision making, so check the current CMS Physician Fee Schedule rule each year.
A note on codes and coverage: This article is educational information about Medicare billing rules, not legal, financial or compliance advice. Medicare rules, fee schedules and payer policies vary and change over time, so always verify the current rule against the CMS Physician Fee Schedule final rule, the Medicare Claims Processing Manual, and the specific payer policy before acting. The payment rates in this article are the Medicare rules stated with them, and the worked example uses illustrative figures only.
Having trouble deciding who bills a shared visit, or with split/shared denials and modifier FS? Neximed Billing provides split/shared visit review, denial management and billing workflow support. Contact us at info@neximedbilling.com or +1-406-2251570.
Related reading: Incident-to Billing: Medicare Requirements · Modifier 25 vs 59 in Medical Billing · Place of Service Codes 19, 21, 23, 24, 31, 32 · Place of Service 11 vs 22 · CMS-1500 Box 24J: Rendering Provider NPI